two ex-lawyers ponder American presidents’ assassination powers, murder disguised as war, pain, life, children, the awful grace of God …

 


Ex-lawyers Tim and Sloan ponder American presidents’ assassination power, murder disguised as war, pain, life, children and the awful grace of God …

Tim
Ever read this:

“People sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf.”

George Orwell

Although I must say that I am very disturbed that the President can order the assassination of American citizens (perhaps I should say anyone) with no kind of check on that power.

Sloan
Been a long time since I slept peaceably in my bed at night, it was October 7, 2006 to be precise. Before that, it was way back in time. Can’t say how it would be if I lived in, say, Africa, Syria, mainland China, N. Korea, Russia.

I imagine the US President always has had the power to order the assassination of American citizens, have not read the law, in certain situations. Which brings the question, who gave him that power? Congress, yes? And who elected the Congress who gave him that power? We the People, right?

Tim
I do not believe you are correct. It would be interesting to determine the source of the presidential power. As I recall there were curbs placed on US assassinations after the revelations of the CIA plots to assassinate Castro. So something has changed since then.

Sloan
After sending mine to you, I saw I had left out some words.

I think US presidents always have ordered wet work, regardless of legality.

I understand something changed recently allowing the president to do it legally in some situations? If so, do you know what enabled that? Was it a new law? A new fiat?

If it came to be, who went along with it coming to be, or passed the law letting it come to be – Congress?

And who elected Congress? We the People.

Tim
Yes I think it is worth researching how the change came about.

Whether Presidents did it before re US citizens I am unsure of.

But there certainly were times we at least tried to assassinate foreign leaders.

TIM

Sloan
Waco, Texas – Branch Davidians

Kent State – students protesting expansion of Vietnam war into Cambodia, wasn’t it?

Not quite on topic, but pretty close.

Tim
Add to that Ruby Ridge.
There are rather convincing reports that before his presidency LBJ used a man named Mac Wallace to kill at least one investigator. No question that Wallace existed and was indeed a murderer. My thoughts on LBJ are so mixed. Caro’s books show how corrupt he was but his civil rights legislation was so important for our country.

Sloan
Now that you dragged LBJ into it, I’ll add Vietnam. I remember watching him promising on TV that he would never send American boys to die in a war in Asia.

I read something maybe two years ago now, making a case for LBJ having ordered the murder of President Kennedy. Don’t recall the details now, but the sense of what I remember was LBJ felt slighted by Kennedy. I have read Kennedy got in dutch with bad folks when he chilled on Vietnam and more than chilled at Bay of Pigs.

Tim
There are indeed many people who believe LBJ was behind the JFK hit, altho I do not think I do. BUT I recently read that after the assassination Jackie made tape recordings with Arthur Schlesinger that were to be sealed for 50 years after her death but will now be released ths fall. According to a British paper, Jackie told Schlesinger she thought LBJ was behind her husband’s murder–which may not prove anything since it was only her suspicion.

LBJ certainly had motive. He was under criminal investigation at the time and many reports say JFK intended to dump him from the ticket.

Bye for now–more later–off to work.

I am in a new book that will be reviewed in Solares next Sunday, I will send you the draft, then quit. The reviewer by the way is a proponent of the LBJ did it theory.

Sloan
I think I explained before that Solares Hill book reviews are a sore subject with me. The novel Mark Howell reviewed, only to have Tom Tuell kill the review, was written by something far bigger and beyond me. After I the book was done falling out of me, I was sure it was my ticket to a normal life, from the making money off it sense. Ha!

Once upon a time I married a woman who had been one of the students at Kent State, sitting in a protest circle on the ground, when the Ohio National Guard opened fire on them. Those not shot got up and ran with the National Guardsmen in pursuit, shooting. When the feeling pod of students veered right, she veered left and nobody chased her. The National Guardsmen were not prosecuted. She never got over it. Never trusted government or police again. Can’t say I blamed her. She was the muse for the novel Mark reviewed. I never saw what he wrote.

I continue to see Vietnam as a mortal wound to the soul of America. That failed military (corporate) misadventure provided the fuel for all future American foreign military adventures via unconscious attempt to atone by winning a war of substance. GW Bush was as bad as LBJ. Obama joined that infamous duo when he accepted the Nobel Peace Prize while waging two GW Bush wars – unconscionable.

Personally, the angels who ride hard on my hide and soul scare me a lot worse than the US Government scares me. They really roughed me up today, which is Father’s Day (2012). What ever possesses people to want to be close to God is beyond my comprehension.

It also became beyond the comprehension of the woman who became the muse for the novel. The angels pulverized us, and when neither of us could take any more, they sent me to the Keys from Maui. That was late 2000.

I’ve been mostly marinating here ever since, although there were a few adventures in North Georgia, Birmingham, and a few other places I’d like to forget.

Tim
I am so sorry for bringing up a sore subject.

What do you think of this quote by Aeschylus? It was a favorite of RFK:

He who learns must suffer
And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget
Falls drop by drop upon the heart,
And in our own despair, against our will,
Comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God.

Historical Note: This was quoted by Robert F. Kennedy in his speech announcing the assassination of Martin Luther King, Jr. on 4 April 1968. His version:

Even in our sleep, pain which cannot forget
falls drop by drop upon the heart
until, in our own despair, against our will,
comes wisdom through the awful grace of God.

It struck me that this seems so close to what you write about the angels beating you up?

It is certainly an interesting quote. I too have some very deep pains, including a bitter divorce and my daughter being estranged from me.

Sloan

Yeah, the awful grace of God sums it up pretty darn well. Maybe angels were beating JFK up, certainly he was put to very rough tests in Cuban Missile Crisis, Bay of Pigs, Vietnam. God tests us in different ways, depending on where we live, our station, circumstances.
 
I know well the pain you describe. Loves lost. Three children lost, one by death, two by their own choice. I did not even remember yesterday was Father’s Day until someone called and reminded me, an “adopted” daughter. Then, she asked me to give her some more money. I have supported her since the summer of 2005 and I figured that was why she really called. I usually get angel-hammered extra hard on special days like birthdays, US government holidays, solstices, All Hallows Eve, Valentine’s, wedding anniversaries, Mother’s Day and Father’s Day. Yesterday was brutal until dark.
The US Open was brutal on a heap of world-class golfers. Grown men broken at the knees by that seriously wicked golf course with narrow fairways, dense roughs, ice greens that sloped toward hell and were nearly impossible to read and judge distance. The winner won by being the least over par after 72 holes – one over. Tiger Woods was crushed the last day. He had lots of company before that, and more company yesterday. Grown men wept. A 25-year-old with a homemade swing shot 2 under par each of the last two rounds and from out of nowhere overtook the pack of legends and rising stars. I was glad he won, I like him. He won’t have to qualify for a tour event for a long time, will get automatic invitations to the majors. He made a bundle yesterday, and God only knows what that did to jack up his product endorsements. 

Tim
A pretty interesting article

A bit too interesting. I learned in law school, and again when I clerked for a US District Judge, and even again when I practiced law, that due process means you get to face your accusers and put on your own evidence and be represented by your own lawyer and you get to do it in a tribunal, legal or administrative, provided by law, and if you don’t like the outcome, you can appeal to a court of law.
To me, this is not about due process at all. It is about war. The American President has broader powers during wartime, if war has been formally declared. Did Congress approve the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? Did Congress approve a general war against Al Qaeda? Those are relevant questions. As is the Geneva Convention. Is the US still bound by it?

All tillitating, but in reality, Tim, it goes back to what I said in the beginning. I wager American presidents going way back have ordered clandestine hits on people deemed to be national threats, be they foreign or American citizens. I think it is naive to believe otherwise. Does that make it right? Probably not. But it is a realistic perspective.

Holder seems focused on Al Quaeda, not on, say, the KKK, Neo Nazis or the New Black Panthers. I don’t agree with Holder, but every Republican in America probably does, if not openly, then secretly.

And that’s the rub, isn’t it? President Obama is just as big, if not even a bigger hawk than was GW Bush. Obama has trumped the Republican’s strongest card: National Defense. Leaving them hollering about the economy. Whether Republicans like it or not, they and GW Bush handed Obama a serious economic mess.

Yeah, Obama made it worse, but don’t you think John McCain also would have made it worse? Maybe not in the same ways Obama made it worse, but in Republican ways McCain would have made it worse. Deep down inside I bet Viet vet prisoner of war hero McCain loves Eric Holder and Barack Obama’s pursuit of Al Qaeda afar and near.

:-)

 
Tim
Well written as always, Sloan.

But I as a Republican believes this goes too far.
Wouldn’t it be interesting if POTUS had to seek a legal order for an execution and target had to come to court to resist it? At least there would be some judicial review and if the target came to court he could be arrested!
I think if I was Romney I’d go after Obama on this. I think he could applaud the war on terror so as not to alienate his base yet possibly pick up some votes from the ACLU.
Here is what I think is the salient paragraph from the article:
To recap Barack Obama’s view: it is a form of “terror” for someone to be detained “without even getting one chance to prove their innocence,” but it is good and noble for them to be executed under the same circumstances.
 
To recap Eric Holder’s view: we must not accept when the Bush administration says “just trust us” when it comes to spying on the communications of accused Terrorists, but we must accept when the Obama administration says “just trust us” when it comes to targeting our fellow citizens for execution.
As it turns out, it’s not 9/11/01 that Changed Everything. It’s 1/20/09.
 
I was estranged from my daughter when he court allowed her mom to move to Missouri.

 
I did not even get a call from her!
(I had been a stay-at-home Dad and raised her until she was about five, all the time working full time a night shift.
Sunday was a sad, sad day for me.
Can hardly get over the pain!
 
Sloan
Of course, it goes too far. At least it seems only aimed at al Qaeda operatives, American or foreign, although that’s pretty subjective and surely opens the door to whatever unimaginable horrors. In it’s present evolution, though, it’s only a flea on an elephant’s butt compared to Vietnam and GW Bush’s wars. But does that change in, say, 10 or 20 years? America collapses from within. Marshall law imposed. Habeas corpus denied. 1984 actualized. Never would have thought that would have started with the Democrats. But then, GW Bush used Guantanamo in much that way, didn’t he? I certainly didn’t trust GW, or his father. I don’t trust Obama. I don’t trust Republicans. I don’t trust Democrats. I don’t trust any religions to do anything good on a reliable basis, and for sure the Republicans and the Democrats are religions. Why don’t you just call youself a person, or a human being? Or even a man?
 
I handled some very rough child custody cases. Not something I’d want to do for very long. Don’t think there is any getting over the pain of that kind of soul trauma. Today is my oldest daughter’s 44th birthday. Haven’t heard from her since early 2000. Saw her at my father’s wake, her sister there, too. They came all the way down from Kentucky to Birmingham. Were staying with her mother and her husband in Tuscaloosa. Tried to arrange to drive down for a lunch or dinner before they headed back to Kentucky. Their mother said they had too much to do, not enough time. I saw the younger one Christmas 1999, in Tuscaloosa. She and her sister there the Christmas before. They both have two children. I never met the younger one’s kids. The older one’s oldest knew me, but the younger was an infant the one time I saw her. I was shown by their mother’s father in a dream about two weeks ago what was the cause of the estrangement. Something the angels told me in the summer of 2000, something awful, not about me, which I was told to spread around. See no way that will ever be overcome. You never get over that kind of pain. Sorry for yours. You now see your daughter some, yes?
 
Tim
Cerainly agree that party discipline asks way too much.

 
I do not think GB was authorizing targeted kills as Obama is.
As the saying goes, power corrupts! (Lord Acton as I know you know).
 
Last saw my daughter for only about ten days last summer.

I talk to her about twice a week on the phone.
The pain of losing her does not go away.
And I lose half my income to child support, and her mon owns a time share in Orlando and they have no money for her college, and she is very bright
Thanks for your story as well, Sloan.
 
Sloan
G.W. Bush authorized mass target kills in Iraq and Afghanistan. Sorry, I’m a great deal more jolted by that kind of presidential murder, because of the numbers of dead, maimed, disappeared, displaced, traumatic-shocked, etc., on both sides.
 
Actually, I don’t know ding squat about Lord Acton, but I know power corrupts. Looks to me everything changed for America when it started messing around in Vietnam. It was tenous before that, the Cold War, but a line was crossed with Vietnam, a line which never got uncrossed. We have the Democrats to thank for Vietnam, and the Republicans to thank for the later Vietnams.
 
Sometimes I dream about my daughters and wake up in convulsive sobbing with my heart feeling like it’s being ripped out of my body. Sometimes I wake up wailing like a wounded animal.
 
A trust my grandfather had set up for me when I was young paid my daughters’ child support until they were eighteen, when I didn’t have to pay child support anymore and stopped the payments. He left them money, too. They both went to Bryn Mawr, which was about like going to Princeton, which was my grandfather’s alma mater. One became an eye surgeon and medical school professor, one became a wife and mother. Didn’t matter to me what they became, as long as it was what they wanted.
 
I always told them when they said they didn’t know what they should do when they got older, to follow their heart, it would take them where they needed to go. I never pushed them academically. And eventually I quit pushing them about anything. Wasn’t my place. Alas, what the angels turned me into and had me do pushed my daughters plenty hard; pushed women I loved plenty hard; pushed friends plenty hard; pushed me a lot worse than plenty hard.
 
A very different discipline than is required in schools, the military, political parties, religion. A discipline imposed from that which there is no escape. Plenty of stories of that discipline in the Bible, but darn if I come across anyone besides Sandy Downs who seems to get what pushes me.
 
Tim
Sometimes I dream about my daughters and wake up in convulsive sobbing with my heart feeling like it’s being ripped out of my body. Sometimes I wake up wailing like a wounded animal.


Oh, Sloan, I know just what you mean!! Ditto!! More on the political issues later. I look forward to reading GMFK every a.m.

 
 

 

2 thoughts on “two ex-lawyers ponder American presidents’ assassination powers, murder disguised as war, pain, life, children, the awful grace of God …

    • My attitude was shaped by angels beating me sensless until I changed by attitude on just about everything, lots of beatings over long period of time, still underway …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>